Showing posts with label All-Party Parliamentary Human Rights Group on Bangladesh. Show all posts
Showing posts with label All-Party Parliamentary Human Rights Group on Bangladesh. Show all posts

Friday, November 5, 2010

War crimes law 'falls short' said International Bar Association

By David Bergman

Dhaka, Mar 14 (bdnews24.com)—An expert panel of international lawyers, including a former war crimes prosecutor, has submitted a legal opinion to the government setting out reasons why Bangladesh's legislation for planned war crimes trials is not compatible with international standards.

The lawyers recommend a further 17 changes to the recently amended International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973, arguing that it contains "significant omissions" regarding protection of rights of those on trial and "out of date" definitions of war crimes.

The legal opinion, written by the War Crimes Committee of the International Bar Association (IBA), was formally submitted at the end of February to the Bangladesh government by the UK's All-Party Parliamentary Human Rights Group who had requested the legal advice.

The UK parliamentary group told bdnews24.com that the Bangladesh High Commission in London had confirmed 12 days ago that it had sent the legal advice to the "relevant government authorities" in Bangladesh.

A spokesperson from the group said, "We are now waiting for a more substantive reply from the relevant government authorities."

Law minister Shafique Ahmed who is out of the country could not be reached for comment, but state minister Kamrul Islam told bdnews24.com on Sunday he had not yet seen the legal opinion.

"I have not officially received a copy of the document. When the law minister returns and we receive a copy, we will review it."

Trial of 1971 war crimes was among the top election pledges of Sheikh Hasina's Awami League government. The government, since coming to power in January last year, has taken a number of steps to put Bangladeshis in the dock who face charges of genocide, rape, arson, looting and abetting the Pakistani occupation forces during the 1971 liberation war.

Among these steps was the amendment of the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973. Law minister Shafique Ahmed tabled the bill for its amendment in parliament last July 8, following a process of consultation with the Law Commission. The parliamentary standing committee on law was given one night to scrutinise the bill, before its passage the following day.

AREAS OF CONCERN

The IBA's War Crimes Committee comprises a 20-member expert advisory board, including Justice Richard Goldstone who was a former chief prosecutor for the International Criminal Tribunal for former Yugoslavia and the International Criminal Court.

They recommend 17 changes to the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973, amended by the government last year, though they do acknowledge that the legislation "provides a system that is broadly compatible with current international standards".

The IBA's "area of greatest concern" in the amended Act involves the rights of individuals on trial where there are "some significant omission of the accepted international standards", according to the legal opinion submitted to the government.

The Act should not allow tribunals to continue in absence of any of its members, the lawyers argue. The accused must also have the right to challenge the constitution of the tribunal as well as the appointment of its members if "possible prejudice" arises during the trial, say the international lawyers.

The provisions concerning the process of investigation, in particular the rules relating to self-incrimination, are "complicated", "confusing" and "should be removed as unnecessary", the legal opinion says.

The lawyers advise that sections of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court dealing with rights of suspects during investigations should be included in the Act. They also propose that Article 14 of the International Covenant on Political Rights which sets out "fundamental principles which protect the rights of individuals before a court of law", should be incorporated.

The legal note raises concerns about definitions of two offences in the Act. It states that the definition of "crimes against humanity" used in the Act "misses an important element of the more modern definition" which says the crimes must be "widespread or systematic" and the accused person must have had "knowledge" of the crimes.

It also says that the offence of "crime against peace" should be deleted as it contains "outdated statutory language which remains undefined in most recent statutes in international criminal law".
http://www.bdnews24.com/details.php?id=155832&cid=2

War Crimes trials should comply with international standards said Lord Avebury, Vice-Chair, Parliamentary Human Rights Group UK


020-7274 4617
ericavebury@gmail.com
ericavebury.blogspot.com

Statement by the office of Lord Avebury, Vice-Chair, Parliamentary Human Rights Group

June 24, 2010

War Crimes trials should comply with international standards

At the request of the All-Party Parliamentary Human Rights Group (PHRG), the War Crimes Committee of the International Bar Association (IBA) examined the compatibility with international standards of the legislation under which the government of Bangladesh intends to hold trials of persons accused of war crimes and crimes against humanity in the war of independence in 1971 . The purpose was not to challenge the right of Bangladesh to try the perpetrators of these crimes, but to ensure that no objection to the proceedings would be likely to arise on the grounds that the 1973 Act was not in conformity with developments in the legal standards developed over the last 37 years.

At the end of 2009 the War Crimes Committee reported its findings to the PHRG, and after internal consideration, the report was sent to the Bangladesh High Commissioner under cover of a letter from the Chair of the PHRG, Ms Ann Clwyd, requesting that it be transmitted to relevant Ministers in Bangladesh, and asking for their comments.

A seminar was held on June 24 in Committee Room 3 of the House of Lords to discuss the IBA report, and the High Commissioner finally sent his government’s comments on June 21. He was unable to attend the seminar or to send a representative.

The main speakers were:

Stuart Alford, Chair of the War Crimes Committee of the International Bar Association
Khandker Mahbub Hossain, President of Supreme Court Bar Association of Bangladesh
Christopher Keith Hall, Senior Legal Adviser, International Justice Project, Amnesty International
Toby Cadman, International Bar Association

The representatives of the IBA reiterated that they would be ready to give detailed advice to the government of Bangladesh on how the legislation could be amended so as to comply with recent norms of international law, in line with models such as the Rome Statute on the International Criminal Court, the International Criminal Tribunal on the former Yugoslavia, the International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda, and national tribunals such as those in East Timor and Sierra Leone. They added that there no doubt were other international legal authorities who would be prepared to offer constructive advice if it were requested.

Lord Avebury undertook to convey this offer of a dialogue to the authorities in Bangladesh


Ends